So Jaykay - with the broomstick method - do you place the chicken on its front or back? and do you face the chicken's head or tail when pulling...
I lie him on his side. His head is facing away from me, I pull his feet upwards, my hands together, one of his feet in each hand, so I have a good grip. I end up with his toes facing me, at chest height, so I've twisted as well as pulled.
Does the chicken start to struggle when it's pinioned under the broomstick but before you pull its neck?
No, they tend to go quiet but you get it done fast anyway.
It's possible to actually pull his head off, which makes a right mess, but at least you know you've done the job. They flap afterwards, sometimes quite a bit. The neck is very clearly broken and you know the job is done. I then leave them to hang so that the blood pools in the neck. If I've pulled the head off, I tie a carrier bag over the neck while the body hangs.
I hate doing it, which is as it should be. I also don't fudge it which is what I owe them. They've given me 6 months of good company and are about to feed me, so in my view it's what I can do for them back, to get over my squeamishness and give them a quick, clean end.