maybe or obviously in the dog world things are different
the dog shows are supposed to place the best dogs first are they not
what is the point of breeding to perfection and stopping that line then breeding from mediocre lines
all breeders should strive for perfection even in canaries

I don't think you quite understand, Robert. Dog showing is not just for breeders, it is a hobby for an awful lot of people who will never breed. It is not the same as showing an animal that will taste good.
Yes, we Judges are supposed to Judge to the Breed Standard, and generally speaking, on the whole the best dogs do win, but as I said above they may not ever be bred from. Also, although I have trained in France (I own a French Breed), and passed the Canine Judging Diploma, and our Breed Seminar exam, all three with Distinction, not everyone has. There are certainly more stringent criteria for judging than there were but there are still a lot of judges around that don't know one end of a dog from another, so to speak. Then again a breed standard is a set of words, not pictures, and as such is open to interpretation. What I might see as a good Brittany, someone else might not like it's head, or tailset, or length of loin, or slope of pastern, or slope of croup - the sum of the parts is what I look for, not an excelling in one thing, although I do like heads to be in the correct proportion, the specific movement of our breed to be correct, oh, and nice bums
