I think that giving in keeps a lot of relationships together, like you MGM, I like the equality I have now...I think due to me being a bit erratic and spontaneous most of the time, sometimes people like to take controle as its the way they feel safe....I detest any form of control and my now husband tries it on all the time, he says he is helping but he is actually interfering and then i get mad.....although he is not as bad as my Ex in any way shape or form, he will just tell me what to do all the time, e.g, phone so and so today, pay the gas bill, hoover the bedroom etc etc, I honestly do not need to be told and hate it, I now understand its things that are going on in his head and he wants them sorted to feel better......on the other hand my Ex used to actually tell me off and was negative about anything and everything I did, even my friends were spoken about in negative ways...anyway, like you say, there needs to be a balance, I suppose your Ex actually likes being controlled... and I hope my ex can find someone who can put up with his insults all the time......he has a nice girlfriend at the moment so who knows???