The Accidental Smallholder Forum
Community => Coffee Lounge => Topic started by: doganjo on September 16, 2012, 07:36:15 pm
-
Has anyone every looked at the number of posts? Following on from Plums going awol and wondering why, I just had a look.
There are 104 pages of members who have never ever posted on here, and another 43 pages who have only posted once or twice - at 30 to a page that is almost 4500 people - where are they all? ::) And why have they never said anything? ???
-
Folk come on looking for an answer to a question, find it and go. And posts in Coffee Lounge don't count.
-
It can be intimidating here. The likes of me don't try to compete: too much hassle.
-
It can be intimidating, but the sub-forums are in place for light introductions.
The main reason is the work it takes to run a forum I would imagine. Its hard to know if a member 'is' a member or a lurker or indeed just a random computer sign-up trying to spam your forum.
It is tru to say that the majority of the 4500 redundant members are infact either created by breaches in forum security in terms of computer sign-up or random people that wil never come back - but its decided who is what and who is who. Its easier to just leave all the members in your database untill you get a few bounces off their email or somethig and then do a big cull every now and then.
-
Some members join to enable them to reply to posts in For Sale .....and I have noticed a few newbies join, put an ad on the for sale board and then never come on again!!
-
I'm sure there are a good few who are intimidated by the forum, I would think many Accidental Smallholders are quiet natured folk.
Some long standing members on here think they own the place and have a holier than thou attitude, frankly not helpful, not welcoming and not typical of the majority of us.
-
I would hope people aren't intimidated. I know there have been problems, which could have put people off, but they all seem to be resolved for the moment. I've been a member since last September so just a year and I have only found people to be helpful and friendly.
I do agree, though, that a lot of people appear then disappear. I try to welcome everyone who introduces themselves but there are many who are never seen again after that. Shame.
-
It can be intimidating here. The likes of me don't try to compete: too much hassle.
Feeling the same, after posting i think what a load of rubbish.
Cant, talk the talk, again to much hassle.
-
I would hope people aren't intimidated.
I like it here and I like to read the other threads, but having seen some of the replies people have been left since I joined, I'd be very wary of asking advice on situations I found myself in. Maybe those with tougher outlooks wouldn't care, but I know I'm sensitive enough to be upset by it so I won't put myself in that position.
Anyway, I'm sure that's not solely responsible for the high numbers of inactive members, I'm pretty sure that's just the nature of forums.
-
Forums in my opinion seem to be hijacked by a chosen few.
As for advice, the jury is still out.
-
And when one of the chosen few has a hissy fit and throws her toys out of the pram all the others gather round in dismay and persuade her to re-join. It happened again yesterday.
When I joined I said I'd keep my head down. Not doing too well at that so far - been shot at twice already
-
Forums in my opinion seem to be hijacked by a chosen few.
As for advice, the jury is still out.
And when one of the chosen few has a hissy fit and throws her toys out of the pram all the others gather round in dismay and persuade her to re-join. It happened again yesterday.
When I joined I said I'd keep my head down. Not doing too well at that so far - been shot at twice already
Two words -
'Nail' and 'Head'
-
Can't understand why anyone would join with the intention of ' keeping ones head down' If we all did that- there would be no forum! . as for ' the chosen few ' who does the chosing?
It's all down to the individual and their personalities, life is too short to worry about what people think of you, so wake up and get posting , so what, If someone take a pot shot at you- simply shoot back , sod e'm , get out there and voice your opinion , not everyone will agree with it , and why should they, it's a debate -not an argument . :thinking:
-
Oh dear what a sad way for the forum to be viewed tho i have to agree with some aspects of these postings
Personally i have found the forum to be in the overall scheme of things a helpful well informed place that has managed to offer us in particular some well measured advice and would hope that on ocassion that hes been reciprocated although due to the very nature of some manners on here both OH and myself refrain from posting and just trawl and read
Of late it has become very much a club 'if you're in you're in and if you're out you're most definitely out' which is a shame some of us aren't quite as keen to be in the limelight as others but aren't defunct of an opinion or an experience to share but have particularly recently been put off doing so
I sincerely hope it sorts itself out soon and would have to add if a post is offensive report it to mods with clearly defined reasons as to why and let them deal with it :sunshine:
-
Quite simply Tiz as previously said not everyone is made of such stern stuff and frankly in some circles only certain opinions count..............in my perception that is :)
-
I keep reading these posts telling me that only the chosen few can post with impunity.
And I can't work out who is chosen and who not!
I post a lot, occasionally get a shot taken at me, sometimes warranted and sometimes less so. If it's warranted I try to make amends, if it's not I usually ignore it - sometimes I ask a member whose opinion I trust whether I've missed something and did phrase something badly, and sometimes it turns out I did and sometimes not.
There are some longstanding members I have on 'ignore' because I know that the way that they post irritates me or because I feel they rarely have anything useful to add. When / if I want to see an individual post I can click on on the 'Show me this post', otherwise I don't have to read what they've written.
I do not have any more recently joined members on 'ignore' because I am still getting to know them and am keen and interested to read everything that they post. A lot of really good advice comes from the more recently joined, and this has always been true.
What am I missing?
-
Well ...
I agree that sometimes it's difficult to see where a poster is coming from, but that can be due to education, background, etc.
My attitude to life is "do as you will be done by" & I hope that is reflected in my postings :fc:
-
Just want to add that I am a member of a big birdwatching forum and have never posted. The reason, because I don't want to and just like keeping up to date with what is going on around the country.
I imagine some people might just join and realise they don't have the time or inclination to join in.
There isn't always a cloak and dagger reason for people joining and not posting.
Helen
-
There isn't always a cloak and dagger reason for people joining and not posting.
Thanks Helen, that's absolutely right. The Forum registration system is also integrated with the site registration system - for instance if someone registers for the online shows they are automatically given a forum membership.
We screen every new member and delete all that are clearly spammers, and put a watch on those that might be.
But many register so they can subscribe to threads and receive email notification, to enter the online shows (but never come near the forum), and many register to post in the Marketplace - all legitimate reasons.
For those who care, we have 6,440 registered members, of which 3,344 have posted at least once. This year we have had an average of just over 1,000 different members posting each month. :thumbsup:
-
Just want to add that I am a member of a big birdwatching forum and have never posted. The reason, because I don't want to and just like keeping up to date with what is going on around the country.
I imagine some people might just join and realise they don't have the time or inclination to join in.
There isn't always a cloak and dagger reason for people joining and not posting.
Helen
I agree Helen, I have friends on here who have been on for years and have only made a few posts.
They enjoy the reading rather than writing.
-
The forum became a bit contentious and this job is hard enough without unnecessary stress.
There's some good information and some excellent advice but the social aspect isn't for me so I've joined the non-posting members. The forum is what it is and obviously works for lots of people. Maybe it will calm down a bit in a few months but it feels better to watch than participate at the moment.