The Accidental Smallholder Forum

Community => Coffee Lounge => Topic started by: bamford6 on July 05, 2011, 10:17:36 am

Title: members being robbed att forfar mart
Post by: bamford6 on July 05, 2011, 10:17:36 am
REGULATIONS A CONDITIONS FOR THE SALE OFF POULTREY A WATERFOWL ,UPSET PRICE ON HATCHINING EGGS A MINIMUM STARTING BID OFF £5 WILL APPLY TO EACH LOT OFF EGGS £1 BELOW WICH THE LOT WILL SELL .IFF THE UPSET PRICE IS NOT BID THE AUCTIONER WILL PASS ON TO THE NEXT LOT . The cost per 12 eggs or tray is  £1 20 iff its not sold YOU pay £1  so the bidder has to pay  £5TO start like it or not  .i put in 10 to 15 lots and iff some 1 gets them for £1 well thats good  but naw its  £5 minimum bid, I WILL NOT SELL MY EGGS UNDER THESE CONDITIONS its July the hatching season is nearly over. i would off put a good selection in the sale  .The pens are £6 inc vat and 10% commission off the sale off each lot. . The sale that was in the spring was not set out right the caterlog was on the day the birds wernt off the floorer. iff they wont a good sale and the money they need to get there act in order first . iv done 6 sales eggs go up at £1 and iff they dont make no more thats itt iv lost and the sale loose but the person gets the eggs for £1, att thainstone i got £53 pound a tray off chocolate orpingtons. iff they made a  £1 so be it ,att Carlyle i got £150 for 12 light Sussex eggs all the eggs are off quality stock .on sunday some folk came for hatching eggs for there  incubator they needed  fresh eggs ,i said iff you pay  £40 and have all off the days eggs you can have them all, no problem i cut the grass and they took the eggs from all the pens some 250 eggs. Att the minute ,you need to be fare with folk .each pen should make £50 to 80 pound they get £6 per pen and 10 % commission ,so its big money for the sale some people will travel 100 miles and make a good effort with there stock . i wonder iff it will be run right or a disaster like the last time. i will send this thread to forfar mart and see iff we can have a caterlog a week before .i think the sales will be set up on members land no commission to these sales bid and take a way the old way off selling eggs and stock .
Title: Re: members being robbed att forfar mart
Post by: lachlanandmarcus on July 05, 2011, 12:00:23 pm
I hope they find it easier to read than I did... :-\

They will probably sit up and take notice if it isnt in 'shouty capitals' and has a few more sentences, it's a bit stream of consciousness?

Only saying this because the points you are making are good ones which they need to address, it would be a shame for them to get away with ignoring it, you want them to read it.
Title: Re: members being robbed att forfar mart
Post by: melodrama on July 05, 2011, 12:37:43 pm
I agree, this is unfortunately a little difficult to read and may not get the point across that you want it to.  Sorry x
Title: Re: members being robbed att forfar mart
Post by: tizaala on July 05, 2011, 12:48:57 pm
I just knew that having a spell check on the reply box was a worthwhile addition, all we need now is a grammar check.
Title: Re: members being robbed att forfar mart
Post by: Sylvia on July 05, 2011, 01:11:39 pm
I got the point perfectly. Do they or do they not want the "little man" to support their market? If they are going to put a minimum on their prices and charge a large selling fee they may find their business struggling.
At our local smallholder's market you take your stuff in, book it in and if it sells, you pay a percentage of the selling price, if not, you take your stock home, no problem.
Our market is a friendly affair with lots of chat and jokes and a lot of bargains and a little bit to be made perhaps and a bit of business being done. I would hate it become a harassed affair with bad feelings.
Have a word with the auctioneers and try to get support from other sellers/ buyers.
Title: Re: members being robbed att forfar mart
Post by: tizaala on July 05, 2011, 06:45:13 pm
Hello Bamford6 , Just trying to help, I do understand your literacy problem, but it might help your posts in future,  after you compose what you want to say but before you actually post , if you click the box that says 'spell check' it will run through what you have written and give you the option of correcting any mistakes before they get published. You will also find the government run adult literacy classes to help people in your situation, you are not on your own, there are lots of people out there who didn't do well at school and caught up later with a little help. call in to your local library and ask about courses in your area.
best wishes and good luck.
Title: Re: members being robbed att forfar mart
Post by: deepinthewoods on July 05, 2011, 06:58:55 pm
whatever.
 i got you bamford. good point, well made.
Title: Re: members being robbed at Forfar mart
Post by: doganjo on July 05, 2011, 09:10:00 pm
For anyone else wishing to criticise someone who puts a lot into this forum, and can't be bothered to try to understand what Gary says, here is his text with spelling and punctuation corrected.  Just you stay as you are Gary!  You have had enough to contend with without having to go and learn stuff.  You can make yourself understood perfectly well.  Hope I got this right, Gary?

Quote
REGULATIONS AND CONDITIONS FOR THE SALE OF POULTRY AND WATERFOWL
Upset price on hatching eggs - a minimum starting bid of £5 will apply to each lot of eggs  £1 below which the lot will sell. If the upset price is not bid the auctioneer will pass onto the next lot. The cost per 12 eggs or tray is  £1.20,  if its not sold YOU pay £1  so the bidder has to pay  £5 to start, like it or not.  I put in 10 to 15 lots and if someone gets them for £1, well thats good,  but now it's £5 minimum bid, I WILL NOT SELL MY EGGS UNDER THESE CONDITIONS!

It's July, the hatching season is nearly over.  I would have put a good selection into the sale.  The pens are £6 inc vat and 10% commission off the sale of each lot.  The sale that was in the spring was not set out right; the catalogue was on the day the birds went off the floor.  If they want a good sale and the money, they need to get their act in order first. I've done 6 sales; eggs go up at £1 and if they don't make no more thats it, I've lost, and the sale loses, but the person gets the eggs for £1.  At Thainstone I got £53 pound a tray of Chocolate Orpingtons. If they made a  £1 so be it!  At Carlisle I got £150 for 12 light Sussex eggs.  All the eggs are of quality stock.  On Sunday some folk came for hatching eggs for their  incubator; they needed  fresh eggs.  I said 'if you pay £40 and have all of the days eggs you can have them all, no problem.' I cut the grass and they took the eggs from all the pens some 250 eggs. At the minute, you need to be fair with folk.  Each pen should make £50 to £80 pound:  They get £6 per pen and 10 % commission, so its big money for the sale.  Some people will travel 100 miles and make a good effort with their stock.  I wonder if it will be run right or a disaster like the last time. I will send this thread to forfar mart and see if we can have a catalogue a week before.  I think the sales will be set up on members land, no commission to these sales, bid and take away, the old way of selling eggs and stock.
Title: Re: members being robbed att forfar mart
Post by: Sandy on July 05, 2011, 09:39:37 pm
bamford, I spell wrong ALL the time, I have to alter what I say to suit the words I can spell!! in fact, I didn't notice as I flash read stuff all the time and I don't have half as much as you to do!!!!

I worked some where once and some one corrected what I had wrote and I was soooooo angry and it was my recording of an incident and not thiers!!!!!!
Title: Re: members being robbed att forfar mart
Post by: jaykay on July 05, 2011, 10:14:02 pm
Gary, your reading and writing are fine, you are getting ideas across which is the whole point of writing. If you want more 'polish' fair enough but if not, don't be stressed about it.
My hubby is the same and also learned at school to make his handwriting so bad they couldn't tell if he was spelling right or not  :D But he was always feeling he should improve things. I asked him if he really wanted to spend time on it, if in fact it was holding him back at all - he decided it wasn't and he'd rather go kayaking  :D

Anyway, back to the point of your post, we've had this trouble with one of our local marts that they don't put a 'reserve' on pens that actually covers the entry fee  >:( I think there should be some sort of minimum for pens and for eggs, below which they don't sell. And then sellers can say 'no, i just need to get rid, sell them whatever' or 'not below the minimum'. Otherwise why would you risk entering good quality birds and eggs. Also no catalogue in advance is hopeless, when i have my sensible head on (rare  ;)) I look at catalogues to see if I'm actually going to go to a sale. 
Title: Re: members being robbed att forfar mart
Post by: Sylvia on July 06, 2011, 08:18:02 am
We don't have to pay for pens at our market, all we pay is the commision on sold lots and the buyers premium on bought lots. We only have a catalogue for the two or three rare and minority breeds sales per year, where the birds are judged (and often found wanting ;D)
Having said this, I think folk would be dropping to the floor in droves if 12 L.S. eggs made £150...........more like £1-50 here!!
Bamford, I can read and spell but, put a column of figures in front of me or ask me to measure up for a shelf and I'm sunk. Figures don't and never have made sense to me. It hasn't made any difference to my life though, I just get someone to do it for me ;D ;D
Title: Re: members being robbed att forfar mart
Post by: pikilily on July 06, 2011, 08:47:32 am
Here, here!!!!! Lisdesxics Rool!!

This is not a formal forum....if we are interested in what our friends say, we listen - no matter how it is said, spelt, or what ever type of language is used.  Lets not get tied up in pedantics.

Gary, you make good points.... as always. Keep expressing your ideas, information and thoughts etc. WE WANT TO HEAR YOUR VOICE - LOUD AND CLEAR !!!

My brother, at this very moment, is climbing Muztagh Ata, one of the highest peaks in China. Its a personal challenge which took many months to prepare for, but as a sideline (because we have a lot of dyslexia in the family) James is raising funds for the British Dyslexia Association. If anyone would like to support this, here's the Just Giving web address for his page.
http://www.justgiving.com/James-Shipton (http://www.justgiving.com/James-Shipton) 

Just a wee plug!!  ::) ::)
Emma T
Title: Re: members being robbed att forfar mart
Post by: Hilarysmum on July 06, 2011, 08:59:36 am
Gary, sorry I dont understand why should they start at £5.00  if it means they will not sell nearly as many trays and anyway starting low encourages people to bid.  I think they are on to a big loser here. 
Anyway I hope your protest reaches the right ears and they actually listen.   :D
Title: Re: members being robbed att forfar mart
Post by: shetlandpaul on July 06, 2011, 09:18:38 am
strangly bamford makes perfect sense to me. what really puts me off posting is when folks think they are better than others. we don't come on forums to be judged on our english. I am dyslexic and i really can't be arsed to spend hours spell checking and grammer checking.
garry you do a great job in a very tough area. for you still to be there proves it.
Title: Re: members being robbed att forfar mart
Post by: Sandy on July 06, 2011, 09:30:22 am
I have always said, if it came to me having to spell and be correct with grammer etc, I would not post, to me this is a way of expressing your thoughts, feelings and advice, if some one wants proper grammer then buy mags or books!!!!!

(I hate being corrected unless its a legal doc!)
Title: Re: members being robbed att forfar mart
Post by: lachlanandmarcus on July 06, 2011, 10:56:00 am
I think this has gone a bit off track.

OP certainly doesnt need to change the way he writes on here (altho' the reality is some wont put in the extra effort needed to read them: that limits the readership a bit for the posts), but nothing at Forfar mart will change unless they take his complaint seriously. And I worry that they won't if it was worded/presented as it was to the forum.





Title: Re: members being robbed att forfar mart
Post by: Daveravey on July 06, 2011, 11:29:41 am
If enough folk can get together, why not hold your own sales ?

As far as i know, you don't need a licence for poultry & waterfowl auctions, plus it gives everyone a decent chance to look over stock.

Held locally once a month or so, could be a good way of making new aquaintances or catching up with old ones.

Plus the added bonus of zero fees   ;D
Title: Re: members being robbed att forfar mart
Post by: melodrama on July 06, 2011, 12:33:17 pm
My point was not to be mean to someone with difficulties in spelling, writing or reading and I think the responses have gone a bit over the top given the posts - I don't think anyone was "having a go"!  However, it is difficult, as I'm sure you all understand, to read something that is not particularly legible.  If Forfar Mart read what was written, it wouldn't be taken seriously and THAT is the problem.  I used to be a solicitor and can tell you that noone in a position of authority will take matters seriously unless they are presented properly.  Obviously the initial post here wasn't to Forfar Mart and therefore shouldn't matter too much but if a similar letter/complaint went to Forfar Mart then I don't think they would consider it.  If anyone is wanting to complain formally and put it in writing, I am more than happy to help out with the grammer etc if it means that the complaint will be taken seriously - which is, of course, the point!!
melanie x
Title: Re: members being robbed att forfar mart
Post by: pikilily on July 06, 2011, 02:41:07 pm
perhaps we do get sensitive about things... ;) .....and yes one can get tied up in politically correct knots !!!

Anyway, it may have been a good idea if those comments/ suggestions about legibility had been made privately, rather than on the public forum, given that they could be taken in a negative way. 

Just an observation, mind!!! ::) ::)
Emma T
Title: Re: members being robbed att forfar mart
Post by: Anke on July 06, 2011, 03:38:59 pm
Funny, I came away from Forfar mart the last time feeling robbed aswell, but it wasn't the Mart that was causing the problems was it Gary? 8)
Nor indeed 6 weeks later when I met you again at Thainstone! Nope, I was quite happy with my dealings inside the Mart but again I seem to have went home with a few birds that were not what I was told they were or what I paid for!

I don't have a problem with your spelling, Gary just your business attitude. 8)
10 cockerels which were sold as girls, chocolate orpingtons that turned out black, light sussex with rose combs, and gold laced wyandotte females - well god knows what they were but when they started to crow they went into the pot.
And not even an apology!

Wow... that is exactly the thing that puts me off buying at auction or on e-bay, especially poultry!

On the other hand I think it is a matter of common courtesy to others to use a spell/grammar checker if available. I could not make anything out of the first post, and yes it would be a shame if serious complaints/suggestions get ignored because of bad spelling/grammar, but it would have gone into the bin in my office too!
Title: Re: members being robbed att forfar mart
Post by: suziequeue on July 06, 2011, 07:14:05 pm
Quote
I am more than happy to help out with the grammer etc
;D ;D ;D

Grammer??

Not a great advert for your skills melodrama   ;) ;)
Title: Re: members being robbed att forfar mart
Post by: deepinthewoods on July 06, 2011, 07:16:15 pm
oooouch!!  ;D
Title: Re: members being robbed att forfar mart
Post by: robert waddell on July 06, 2011, 07:25:04 pm
i like this thread                just sitting on the side :D :farmer: :wave:
Title: Re: members being robbed att forfar mart
Post by: jaykay on July 06, 2011, 07:25:59 pm
 ;)
Title: Re: members being robbed att forfar mart
Post by: pikilily on July 06, 2011, 07:30:35 pm
acht.....I give up !!! ;) :D ;D
ET
Title: Re: members being robbed att forfar mart
Post by: Sandy on July 06, 2011, 08:31:48 pm
 :) Happiness is enjoying what you are and what you have not what you wish you had or what you wish you were.....a lot of millionairs are not hot with grammer or spelling...I am neither hot or rich by a long shot on both counts!!!
Title: Re: members being robbed att forfar mart
Post by: bamford6 on July 06, 2011, 09:34:51 pm
iv never had money i invest in big things tractor etc then lend for cash
Title: Re: members being robbed att forfar mart
Post by: Sandy on July 06, 2011, 09:52:18 pm
Thats good thinking and business, plus doing others who cannot afford the big stuff a favor!! ;)
Title: Re: members being robbed att forfar mart
Post by: melodrama on July 06, 2011, 10:13:27 pm
Quote
I am more than happy to help out with the grammer etc
;D ;D ;D

Grammer??

Not a great advert for your skills melodrama   ;) ;)


ha ha oops - just goes to show eh ha ha we are all fallible ha ha  ::) ::) ;D ;D :-*
Title: Re: members being robbed att forfar mart
Post by: Sandy on July 06, 2011, 10:26:07 pm
I used a spell and a grammar check on an important report for a disabled boy when I work in Social Services, as I was in a hurry I did not read the corrections too well so printed copies for all the panel to readm and it ended up me saying in the report   "...he is a well manured boy and goes to school in a posh chair" ;)
Title: Re: members being robbed att forfar mart
Post by: shetlandpaul on July 07, 2011, 08:23:10 am
whever Gary cheated you or not is not really an issue for this forum. You should know enough about the animals that you are buying not to get cheated. If he cheated you he was wrong however thats just your word and has he breeds them for a business i hope you can prove it because you could damage his business.
If he did mess up i m sure gary will sort out the error.
Title: Re: members being robbed att forfar mart
Post by: bamford6 on July 07, 2011, 09:58:59 am
Hi Gary

My incubator just stopped working last night with 6 cream legbar eggs still with 12 days to go so Im gutted 

Will be pestering for another incubator but in the mean time do you have any cream legbar hen chicks? and if you do how much would they be?  Also what price for two LF Chocolate Orp hens? 

Will be at Thainstone on Saturday so can meet you there.
another forum member happey ..........
Title: Re: members being robbed att forfar mart
Post by: Dan on July 07, 2011, 12:07:13 pm
This topic has been locked now.

For future guidance, please don't hijack threads and post off-topic.

BlueDaisy, regardless of the legitmacy of your grievance with Gary this is not the place to air it.  Please resolve it between you, or raise it with Trading Standards or the mart if you're not happy - the purpose of the forum is not to referee in disputes or act as a barometer of breeder quality. Accusing someone of lying in a business transaction is a serious matter, and potentially libellous - please consider carefully whether you wish your last post to remain in a publicly accessible forum.

As you have said yourself, poor business practice will harm a business. The problem is that often bad experiences are shared, while good experiences aren't, so all we see are the complaints and mistakes.

Thanks,

Dan