The Accidental Smallholder Forum

Livestock => Poultry & Waterfowl => Topic started by: Mays on April 14, 2011, 06:01:23 pm

Title: hi, hatching eggs with broody
Post by: Mays on April 14, 2011, 06:01:23 pm
Right, I now have a very broody hen!

so, what do I do next?? the problem is I have only two hens, and they normally sit in the same nest to lay their egg, however since one of them has gone broody & stopped laying, the other hen sits on top of her and lays her egg that the broody then sits on. So I have been removing the egg ever day & have shooed the broody hen out of the nest and shut it up, however its a losing battle so should I just get some for her to hatch?

if I get her eggs, do I need to put her in a seperate hutch?
Title: Re: hi, hatching eggs with broody
Post by: darkbrowneggs on April 14, 2011, 06:32:28 pm
Hi there - it might be worth checking hatching with a broody (http://www.darkbrowneggs.info/#/hatching-with-a-broody/4542303150)  If you are still stuck post again or pm me

All the best
Sue
Title: Re: hi, hatching eggs with broody
Post by: OhLaLa on April 14, 2011, 06:34:29 pm
Two options; If you don't want chicks, block off the nest so neither can get to it. Give them another nest.

OR

Give your broody some eggs to incubate. Mark them with an X on one side and an O on the other so you can clearly identify them.. Remove any unmarked egg each day.

When the time is near for them to hatch (28 days) put the whole nest and broody (late in the evening pref) into a large cat/dog cage (large enough to take food/water, keeping it in the same place). Then the broody will hatch her eggs without the other hen getting in to lay.

You could of course give the broody eggs and keep the other girl out of the nest area altogether if you have other nests.

Look after the broody and her chicks accordingly. Your other girl will lay in a new place if she can't access the usual nest.

Let us know how it goes.

 :chook:
Title: Re: hi, hatching eggs with broody
Post by: Mays on April 14, 2011, 09:01:03 pm
thank you very much for the replies. I have spent the whole evening reading up on the subject, so I am going to "hatch" a plan! I am sure I will be back for a little support, but we are in no way short of room so I think its just a matter of implementing a well thought out plan  ;)
Title: Re: hi, hatching eggs with broody
Post by: OhLaLa on April 15, 2011, 09:06:39 am
I should have mentioned - in order for the eggs to hatch - you have two hens AND a cockerel?

 :-[   ::)
Title: Re: hi, hatching eggs with broody
Post by: bamford6 on April 15, 2011, 10:33:39 am
i put the green tomarto boxes in the coop on sheves as 1 goes dawn i move to a pen on there own iv had 10 in and all goes ok some mothers share the chicks.
Title: Re: hi, hatching eggs with broody
Post by: Mays on April 15, 2011, 09:40:23 pm
ok, I have a plan  :-\

I do have a safe shed to move her to, so the plan is to move her tommorrow night into it by moving the eggs she is sat on and the straw into an apple box, then move the apple box and her into the new shed. My question is, will placing the eggs into the apple box be enough for her to understand or will she just try and go back to the original nesting box?

Yes I need to buy eggs for her to sat on, she is currently sat on some spare unfertiled eggs
Title: Re: hi, hatching eggs with broody
Post by: OhLaLa on April 16, 2011, 07:33:11 pm
Chances are she will get off and go back to the other nest, but as the eggs are not fertile and no good for anything now anyway you are losing nothing by trying. She may stay put, in which case you need to get some fertile eggs under her pronto.

 :chook:
Title: Re: hi, hatching eggs with broody
Post by: goosepimple on April 16, 2011, 07:52:55 pm
I've found in the past that once they go broody they are pretty much quite far down the line of being determined to sit - she probably will go back to her original site so I would just shut her in to the new area with the live eggs (we have been semi-successful with ebay eggs) and eventually she will sit on them and decide she's quite happy.  Don't pussy foot around the whole moving her thing - we used to wait until the hens were off or a break then sneak in with the live eggs etc - now we just pick the hen up, stick the new eggs in with some of her warm ones and stick the hen back on - quick and its over before they know what's going on - its never been a problem - our ducks are the same.  They go into a kind of zombified heated state when sitting and once they've decided that's what they want to do they'll keep on trying.  Good luck - but remember you almost always get twice as many cockerels as hens.  Alternatively you can dunk the hen in a bucket of cold water - sounds drastic but it takes the heat out and shocks them out of their hormonal state. 
PS Just re-read this and I sound brutal (just busy that's all!)  Good luck.
Title: Re: hi, hatching eggs with broody
Post by: OhLaLa on April 17, 2011, 09:26:09 am
Alternatively you can dunk the hen in a bucket of cold water - sounds drastic but it takes the heat out and shocks them out of their hormonal state. 

In all my years I've never heard of or done this. I wouldn't put the hen through that, unnecessary.

 :chook:
Title: Re: hi, hatching eggs with broody
Post by: jaykay on April 17, 2011, 09:35:10 am
You don't have to drown her. You stand her in the water, so that it cools down her legs and, more to the point, her chest. Hold her there for a while - she will object, but hens are not noted for their water habits.

 It's the fastest way to break a broody, and therefore the kindest in the long-run - much nicer than keeping her isolated with little food, which is often recommended.
Title: Re: hi, hatching eggs with broody
Post by: goosepimple on April 17, 2011, 08:55:48 pm
Thanks jaykay - that's what I meant - it is quickest and best, you just prolong the agony for them otherwise as they just go broody again - I didn't mean to drown the poor things! :o ::)
Title: Re: hi, hatching eggs with broody
Post by: Mays on April 18, 2011, 08:19:50 pm
thanks for all the advice, she is still sitting on my Tescos Finest! but the real mccoys arrive tomorrow, but now th eother hen is getting broody & starting to sit on the tescos eggs... & they are moving them from nest to nest. The nests are next to each other, as they used to share a nest but since the brooding started they started sitting on top of each other.
Title: Re: hi, hatching eggs with broody
Post by: Helencus on April 18, 2011, 09:17:01 pm
I have 2 broodys. 1 has been sat on her eggs 4 weeks but no hatch so they must be no good the other 2 days. I have some eBay eggs coming probably tomorrow so I'm going to take the duds out and pop thereby ones under her. The thing that worries me is she eats and drinks so little.
Any tips for keeping her strength up?
Title: Re: hi, hatching eggs with broody
Post by: goosepimple on April 19, 2011, 09:50:58 am
The sitting on top of each other wasn't a problem for us last year - once the eggs were hatched they just all went about in a group with a mum and an aunty, all quite happily.  All happy hippy sharing and chicks didn't mind either.
Hens can dehydrate if the weather gets really hot and this can be a problem - if they're inside or in semi-shade they should be ok but keep clean water and grain nearby (I always use mixed corn with some black sunflower seeds in which they love) but you don't really want the other hens coming in and eating it all so best to put a free-for-all bowl nearby.  I often put a lump of wet bread just in front of them (within pecking distance) each morning too as its easy for them to eat and it makes sure they get liquid.  We used to fuss and worry a lot, then we came to a place where we inherited some wild hens that just sat under bushes and in workshop cupboards and had all their chicks - they didn't want attention and they all had their chicks and lived quite happily, teaching their wee ones how to clamber up to roost in the trees when they were about 4 weeks old - it stopped us fussing.  They can take care of themselves quite easily. 
By the way, ebay eggs - we used to let them sit for 24 hours tried not to move them etc - now we just stick them under the hen/duck straight away - we've done it many times and it didn't make any difference to the number we got - get a good supplier though - a couple of times we have had surprises (not what we ordered).
Also, just for the record, the cooling of the hen in a bucket of water to take her out of her broody state was something we learnt from watching River Cottage - pressumably Hugh got that from chicken whisperer Pammy Riggs (its not something I made up)!  Happy chicking! :D
Title: Re: hi, hatching eggs with broody
Post by: Helencus on April 19, 2011, 01:11:04 pm
Thanks goosepimple. I've been giving them bread soaked in water. Will try the above and maybe a bit of porridge too.
Title: Re: hi, hatching eggs with broody
Post by: Mays on April 19, 2011, 04:05:21 pm
hey, great more tips  :)

I have given her her own water supple & corn stash, i will give her some nibbles by teh next too. The other hen is starting to sit, so should I get her a batch of eggs to sit on too? I really do have plenty room, and the more the merrier! its so exciting  ;D

i will pick her up some sunflower seeds at my next visit to shop
Title: Re: hi, hatching eggs with broody
Post by: goosepimple on April 19, 2011, 07:36:44 pm
There are quite a few types of sunflower seeds - for some reason with my hens it has to be the pure black coloured ones..(?)
Title: Re: hi, hatching eggs with broody
Post by: Helencus on April 19, 2011, 08:40:13 pm
Ive put the eBay eggs under the broodies tonight and they've settled well. I've thrown away the ones they were sitting on as no idea if they're due to hatch at the same time and if they're alive or dead. sad really as some were definately developing or had been but thought it best to start again in a controlled way.
Here's hoping for a good hatch.
Title: Re: hi, hatching eggs with broody
Post by: goosepimple on April 20, 2011, 10:43:28 am
Good luck, it's very exciting and you'll be counting the days - by the way another TAS user I met recently give all her livestock (geese/hens etc) raisins - its a good way to get them to come to you and easy to carry around and easy for them to eat - they all yummy them up (not the chicks of course - have to be careful what I say these days!)
Title: Re: hi, hatching eggs with broody
Post by: Helencus on April 20, 2011, 09:27:11 pm
Good tip I've loads of raisins cheers  ;D
Title: Re: hi, hatching eggs with broody
Post by: Mays on May 10, 2011, 11:20:24 am
well today is day 21! and one of the eggs has a pip this morning  ;D ;D  ;D The Broody hen is in charge and not happy at me having a peek, so I am going to leave her to it & hope we have something to show for it by tomorrow :chook:
Title: Re: hi, hatching eggs with broody
Post by: jaykay on May 10, 2011, 08:00:11 pm
Sounds good  ;D
Title: Re: hi, hatching eggs with broody
Post by: Helencus on May 10, 2011, 08:39:51 pm
Had to take the eggs off my broody she killed one of the chicks as it hatched. I put the other eggs in the incubator and 2 hatched so they've gone in with the other chicks. Broody has gone back in with flock and she seems happy enough and chicks are fine.
Title: Re: hi, hatching eggs with broody
Post by: Mays on May 11, 2011, 01:56:41 pm
I now have one nice fluffy chick & 4 remaining egss.. are they likely to hatch now, the fluffy one hatched last night, none of other eggs are pipped?
Title: Re: hi, hatching eggs with broody
Post by: doganjo on May 11, 2011, 02:04:26 pm
There are quite a few types of sunflower seeds - for some reason with my hens it has to be the pure black coloured ones..(?)
I got some wild bird food fro my hens the other day and have taken out some of teh black sunflower seeds
to try to grow them on.  Probably a waste of time but I like experiments. Strange really because I was rubbish at Science in school ::) ;D
Title: Re: hi, hatching eggs with broody
Post by: ellisr on May 11, 2011, 02:49:13 pm
I now have one nice fluffy chick & 4 remaining egss.. are they likely to hatch now, the fluffy one hatched last night, none of other eggs are pipped?

Always give 3-4 days after the first one has hatched to let the others hatch
Title: Re: hi, hatching eggs with broody
Post by: goosepimple on May 11, 2011, 04:01:22 pm
Good luck with the additional hatchlings - sometimes clumsy mums kill them by accident with their big daft feet (probably a cockerel anyway so saved you a job later).  Good luck.